I just had my end of year evaluation with my administrator. It went well! I had done everything that I needed to in order to prepare for it. While I wasn’t a perfect instructional coach this year (we never are) I owned up to my growth areas and my success stories. Here is a collection of Do’s and Don’ts for your end of year evaluation, that I’ve learned over the years.
Most coaches get far less feedback during the year than the teachers they support, so this one meeting carries a lot of weight. Your principal has a form and a few minutes, and what you carry into the room decides whether those minutes are spent guessing at what you did all year or looking at evidence of it. The good news is that almost everything you need is already in your files; the preparation is mostly about pulling it together and deciding what to lead with.
What does a strong end of year evaluation look like for a coach?
It starts with your goals. My Principal has a lot on her plate. She oversees so many different employees, is constantly dealing with parents, and answers to other administrators. While she can remember my basic duties, she doesn’t always remember the key aspects of my job. I started out my meeting by reminding her of the goals that I had shared with her for myself at the beginning of the year. The best way for her to evaluate me is to measure my progress towards those goals.
Be prepared to talk about what you did with respect to each of these goals. For example, one of my goals was to work with teachers on assessment. I brought documentation of my Coaching Sprints (coaching cycles) with teachers that showed implementation of different assessment strategies, times when I co-created assessments with teachers, and PD I had provided on assessment.
Then it addresses the goals your principal had for you. Remember, your principal is the one driving the ship. You may have met every single goal that you set for yourself, but if you can’t demonstrate that you served the needs of the school, you’ve failed in their eyes. Have evidence of meeting the requirements of your job: a calendar of all the PD you delivered, documentation of your Coaching Sprints, a list of PD you attended yourself, and so on.
And it rests on data, with stories layered on top. While stories and anecdotes are great ways to communicate, they aren’t enough to prove your value, so share all the data you’ve collected over the course of the year, in this order:
- Student-centered data gathered on state tests and during Coaching Sprints. Look for evidence of growth after an intervention or new strategy was implemented. Everything we do should be aligned with improving student learning.
- Teacher data, such as how many teachers implemented the strategies you introduced, the professional development teachers participated in, and reflections from teachers about their own growth.
- Survey results from the teachers you work with about your performance as a coach. This feedback gives evidence to back up whatever you have said about yourself.
Your end of year evaluation is also your time to brag a little. Tell your success stories and celebrate the moments that you are proud of. Your principal is likely exhausted and stressed, and hearing positive news about things that are going well will make the meeting a lot more pleasant for both of you. You might also mention the conferences you are planning to speak at. It makes you and your school look good when you get out there and share your success with the greater public.
Why the way a coach handles the evaluation changes next year
You will undoubtedly miss the mark on some of your goals. Perhaps test scores were lower than they should have been, the science teachers complained that you weren’t able to help them align assessments to their standards, or you didn’t provide enough resources for a new initiative. Whatever the case may be, own it. Explain to your principal that you understand that you fell short and that you are taking the steps to grow from the experience. It doesn’t look good to get defensive. You haven’t failed if you haven’t given up yet.
Whatever you do, do not blame teachers for any shortcomings. This is the equivalent of teachers putting the onus on their students. Yes, students and teachers share some responsibility in their own growth, and your job is to help them grow. Keep a growth mindset yourself and show how you are learning to reach all teachers. One of your most important roles as a coach is to be a cheerleader for the teachers you work with, and a principal who hears you blame them in May will wonder what you say about them in October.
Finally, use the meeting to begin thinking about next year. Naming the goals you want to set, the Anchors you think the building should focus on, and the support you’ll need shows your principal that you have no intention of staying stagnant; you have your own growth and the growth of the school at heart.
How do you prepare for your end of year evaluation as a coach?
The preparation is a week of pulling files, never a night of panic. Start with the goals you wrote in the fall and the goals your principal gave you, gather the evidence for each, pull the student, teacher, and survey data, pick two or three stories worth telling, and write down what you want to do differently next year. The seven steps below are the do’s and don’ts in the order I work through them, and the download gives you the detail for each one and a prep sheet to fill in before the meeting.
- 1Remind your principal of your goals
- 2Address the goals your principal set
- 3Own your shortcomings
- 4Never blame teachers
- 5Share your success stories
- 6Bring data, never anecdotes alone
- 7Be forward thinking
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
Own the year, then look ahead
Walk in with your goals, your evidence, and your misses, and the meeting becomes a conversation between two people who care about the same building. Celebrate what worked, own what didn’t, and leave your principal with a clear picture of where you’re taking your coaching next.
Keep reading: How to Show Your Coaching Is Working and Setting Coaching Goals That Go Beyond “Make Teachers Better”.
Questions people ask
What should an instructional coach bring to an end of year evaluation?
Bring the goals you set in the fall, evidence against each one, and evidence that you met the principal's goals for your role: a calendar of PD delivered, Coaching Sprint documentation, and PD you attended. Add student data, teacher implementation data, and the results of your teacher survey.
How does an instructional coach show their impact to a principal?
Lead with student-centered data from state tests and Coaching Sprints, looking for growth after a strategy was implemented. Follow with teacher data, such as how many teachers used the strategies you introduced, and finish with teacher feedback about you as a coach.
What should a coach do if they missed their goals this year?
Own it. Tell your principal you understand you fell short and name the steps you're taking to grow, without blaming teachers or getting defensive. You haven't failed if you haven't given up yet.
