I struggled with where to place “data” in the sequence of issues about small group instruction. The reason it was so hard for me to decide was because data is part of every stage in the process. Before, you use data to form groups. During, you use it to plan activities and lessons. Afterwards, you use it to measure success and growth. Data is everywhere.
That being said, don’t let data scare you! You don’t need to be a statistics whiz or a computer scientist to use data well. Data is just information. The question is which information you need at each stage, and what you do with it once you have it. Let’s dive into using data to drive small group instruction, from the groups you form in the first week of a unit to the picture of growth you look at in May.
What data do you need before, during, and after small group instruction?
Planning small group instruction starts with data. Even though small group instruction is based on specific skill gaps and never on overall achievement level, holistic grade level assessments are a good place to start. One great source of this type of data is norm-referenced or criterion-referenced assessments like the NWEA or state level tests. Another is your own beginning of year assessment, which gives you information about where each student is with respect to each standard. For reading groups, you’ll also need to know the Lexile level of each student as well as specific skill information like phonics, word recognition, and fluency. Give a diagnostic assessment at the beginning of each unit that is targeted only on the standards in that unit, and include questions that target the prerequisite skills needed to learn the new content. Finally, consider other data like IEPs, 504s, and language proficiency for English learners. The more data the better. Use the aggregate of all of this information to separate the class into groups.
A note on groupings: small group instruction works best when the groups aren’t too big. If you target individual skills, this should happen naturally. If a very large number of students need help with the same skill, reteach it to the whole class in place of a small group. Groups should also be flexible, and this is where formative assessment data comes in.
Once your groups are formed, things start to get interesting. You need to collect frequent formative data to inform your next move with each group. The goal of formative data is to answer these questions:
- Are the students making progress?
- What instructional practices and activities are working for each group?
- What skills should I prioritize when working with each group?
- Are the groups still working, or do some students need to be moved?
- Which groups need more of my time and attention?
There are loads of ways to gather formative data: anecdotal evidence from listening in on students explaining their work, the questions students ask, performance on quizzes, homework, and exit tickets, “show what you know” opportunities, concept maps, conferences with students, and success checks. You may also consider giving a middle of the year assessment that is aligned with the beginning of year assessment you already gave, which gives you a more holistic picture of how far each student has come and helps you reestablish those large categories of at, above, or below grade level.
After the unit, use summative assessments like unit tests and projects to determine the effectiveness of the small groups. Based on these results, you may change the way you use groups in the next unit. You might decide that some groups need more instructional time or more opportunities for skill practice, and you might mix up the groupings, because some students will have mastered the targeted skill while others need more time with it. At the end of the year, give an end of year assessment to get an accurate and aligned picture of each student’s growth, and look at the data on end of year benchmarks and norm-referenced and criterion-referenced tests to ensure that all students made progress. While you won’t use this end of year data to inform further interventions with this class, it will tell you whether your small group instruction had the intended effect: helping all students grow.
Why formative data changes what happens in classrooms
Small assessments guide your immediate next steps as a teacher. They tell you which group to sit with tomorrow, which activity to swap out, and which student has outgrown the group you put them in two weeks ago. They also help students understand where they are in the learning progression, so the groups stay flexible in students’ minds as well as yours. When you bring that same formative data to a Coaching Sprint (coaching cycle) with your coach, it becomes the shared evidence the two of you use to decide what to try next and whether it worked.
How do you analyze formative data to plan your next small group?
Collecting the data is the easy part. The protocol below is how you turn a stack of exit tickets into a decision about who sits at your table tomorrow and what you’ll do with them. It starts by sorting student work into three categories, low (objective not met), medium (objective met), and high (exceeding objective), and then digs into a few pieces from each pile to find the misconceptions, the mistakes with the new material, and the things students already understand that you can build on. The full steps, with the Formative Data Analysis Protocol, are in the download.
- 1Sort student work into three categories
- 2Choose a few pieces to analyze deeply
- 3Look for misconceptions and prerequisite gaps
- 4Note common mistakes with new material
- 5Name what students already understand
- 6Decide what to reteach in small groups
- 7Re-sort groups and plan the next check
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
Data is information you already have
You are already collecting most of this data every day in the questions students ask and the work they turn in. Using it to drive small group instruction is a habit of looking at it on purpose, before, during, and after, and letting it tell you what each group needs next.
Keep reading: Helping Teachers Plan What Happens at the Small Group Table and Guided Groups or Small Groups? Helping Teachers Choose.
Questions people ask
What data should you use to form small groups?
Start with holistic grade level data such as NWEA or state tests and your own beginning of year assessment, then give a diagnostic at the start of each unit that targets the unit's standards and prerequisite skills. Add IEPs, 504s, and language proficiency data, and use all of it together to form groups.
How do you know when to change small groups?
Collect frequent formative data, such as exit tickets, quizzes, student questions, concept maps, and conferences, and ask whether each group is still working or some students need to be moved. Unit tests and projects tell you whether to reshape the groups for the next unit.
How do you analyze formative assessment data?
Sort student work into low, medium, and high categories, then choose a few pieces from each to study closely. Look for common misconceptions, gaps in prerequisite knowledge, mistakes with the new material, and what students already understand that you can build on.
