After an observation, your principal tells you that you need to be differentiating more. You think to yourself, “They don’t understand! Differentiation is easy with younger students that don’t have the pressure of state tests! My students all need to pass the same test. They have to be able to do these math problems and read this level of text! We don’t have time for differentiation!”
If you’ve had these thoughts before, you’re not alone. And yet, differentiation in the upper grades is possible. More importantly, our students deserve it.
There were days while teaching 5th grade that I worked with one student on a challenging word problem that involved the distance formula. Two minutes later, I gave a mini lesson to a small group of students, reviewing the rules of addition, a concept they should have mastered years ago! Even within that mini-lesson I needed to draw pictures, use manipulatives, and show a variety of examples before all the students “got it”. That range is the normal condition of an upper grade classroom, and the three phases below are how I learned to plan for it.
What does differentiation in the upper grades look like?
Student learning can be simplified to three stages: exposure to new knowledge or information, the opportunity to use and explore that information so it is ingrained in long term memory, and demonstration of understanding. As you plan for differentiation, consider how you can tailor each of these phases to the needs of each student. Here is an 8th grade math standard, in plain words: know the formulas for the volumes of cones, cylinders, and spheres and use them to solve mathematical and everyday problems. I’ll refer to this standard as we walk through each phase.
Exposure to content
In this stage, differentiation requires being flexible about the ways that new information is delivered to students. A lecture will not work for all of them. Give students access to videos, text, and hands-on experiences as they build content knowledge, and be prepared with a variety of supporting materials: action steps, note-taking guides, manipulatives, and extra time for the students who need it. For our 8th grade math standard, students might pick one of these options to learn about the volume of cones, cylinders, and spheres:
- Watch the video I created and take notes using the graphic organizer.
- Read pages 257 to 262 in your textbook and take notes using the graphic organizer.
- Use the guided discovery sheet to arrive at the formulas yourself, then test your ideas on a few examples. Record your discoveries in the graphic organizer.
These options all provide students with the same new information, the formulas for volume, and they all end up recording those formulas in the same graphic organizer. Students choose the path that best meets their needs.
Learning opportunities
Now that students have been exposed to new information, they need time to explore it, practice it, and use it. Worksheets have a place here, and some students will benefit from them, so keep offering them as an option. Good differentiation simply means going beyond the worksheet and providing a wider variety of learning opportunities. As students practice using the formulas for volume, they might choose two of these:
- Practice on IXL until you get a mastery score of 90.
- Compare the volumes of three differently shaped glasses. Which one will hold the most soda? Compute the volumes, then test it with a bottle of soda.
- Use flashcards to test yourself on the formulas for volume.
- Solve the volume word problems packet.
- With a partner, solve more complicated volume problems.
Again, all options achieve the same goal, students practice the content. While they work, you can provide remediation in small groups to students who need more support.
Demonstration of learning
Along the way, use success checks and exit tickets to formatively assess your students’ learning. They’ll take a summative assessment once you (and the students) feel confident that they’ve got it. Sometimes good differentiation requires giving up a little bit of control. You don’t have to require all students to take a test or write the exact same five paragraph essay on “The Giver.” If you truly understand the content standard, you will be able to tell whether a student has mastered it regardless of how they choose to demonstrate it. For our standard, students might choose one of these summative options to show they have mastered volume:
- Create a video to teach next year’s class how to calculate volume.
- Find a piece of furniture in your house and think of it as a collection of cones, cylinders, spheres, and prisms. Use the formulas to calculate the total volume.
- Take a test.
- Write a test and an answer key all about volume.
- Create a game that involves volume.
Why differentiation changes what happens in upper grade classrooms
Good teachers recognize that every student carries their own skills, knowledge, gaps, and misconceptions. Even if they attended the same school and had the same teachers, they may have completely different prior knowledge. We do our students a disservice if we teach them all the same way, at any age.
Differentiation does not mean that you accept different levels of mastery. It doesn’t mean that some students only need to solve one step equations while others have to solve multistep. Everybody achieves the same end goal. It’s the path that is subject to change. That distinction is also what your coach is watching for in a Snapshot, a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit: whether every student in the room is headed toward the same standard, and whether the choices in front of them lead there by more than one route.
How do you plan differentiation across the three phases?
The key to effective differentiation is knowing your students and knowing your content. Take the time to understand their strengths, gaps, and interests, and know the standard inside and out so you can be creative with the ways students explore it. The steps below take one standard through all three phases, from the first exposure to the summative choice. The full steps, with the Three-Phase Differentiation Planner, are in the download.
- 1Know your students' strengths and gaps
- 2Know the standard inside and out
- 3Offer two or three ways to learn it
- 4Build a menu of practice options
- 5Pull small groups while students practice
- 6Check understanding with exit tickets
- 7Let students choose how to show mastery
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
Same goal, different paths
Differentiation in the upper grades never means lowering the bar; it means building more than one road to it. When you know your content inside and out, you can be creative with the opportunities you give your students to explore it. They deserve it.
Keep reading: Guided Groups or Small Groups? Helping Teachers Choose and Helping Teachers Plan What Happens at the Small Group Table.
Questions people ask
What does differentiation mean in upper grade classrooms?
Differentiation means every student reaches the same end goal by a path that fits their skills, gaps, and prior knowledge. It never means accepting different levels of mastery; the standard stays the same and the route to it changes.
How do you differentiate instruction in middle school math?
Plan across three phases. Offer choices for how students first learn the content, such as a video, a textbook reading, or a guided discovery sheet, then a menu of practice options, and finally a choice of ways to demonstrate mastery, from a test to a teaching video.
How can you differentiate when all students take the same state test?
Keep the standard fixed and vary the path. Students can learn the content through different media, practice it through different activities while you pull small groups for remediation, and show mastery in different ways, all while working toward the same tested standard.
