Get Simple Insights Every Week LOGIN CONTACT
Simply Coaching
All Insights

Coaching Sprints · Issue 12 · Oct 8, 2019

Helping Teacher Teams Look at Student Work Together

How coaches guide teacher teams to review student work with a clear protocol, find patterns, and plan the next instructional move together.

A fourth grade team sits down for their weekly meeting. Each teacher brings a stack of exit tickets. Ten minutes in, the conversation has turned to scheduling, a field trip, and a parent email. The exit tickets stay in their folders.

Most teams want to use student work. What they’re missing is a clear structure that keeps the work on the table and moves the group toward a decision.

That’s where a coach can help. Many schools know this practice as a critical friends group or a looking-at-student-work protocol. The goal is simple: teachers study what students produced and plan what to do next, together.

What does it mean to look at student work as a team?

Looking at student work as a team means teachers bring a common task, sort the samples, and talk about what students understand and where they’re stuck. The talk stays on evidence. Teams describe what they see before they explain why it happened.

In a Team Coaching Sprint (coaching cycle), this work has a clear home. The team sets one student-centered, measurable BIG Goal, then moves through a series of Moves. Each Move runs a PAR cycle: Plan, Act, Reflect. The Reflect step uses the REVIEW Teams Protocol, a structured way for teams to review evidence and student work. Coaches can also use it 1:1 with a single teacher.

What does a team student work review look like?

Picture the same fourth grade team two weeks later. The coach opens with the BIG Goal and the common task. Each teacher brings five samples: two strong, two partial, and one that missed the mark. The team follows the protocol:

  • Teachers sort samples and describe what they notice, without judging.
  • The team names patterns in student thinking across classrooms.
  • The group agrees on one instructional move to try before the next meeting.
  • Everyone leaves knowing what evidence to bring back.

The meeting ends with a shared plan and a date to look again. Over a few rounds, teachers start to see which moves help students and which ones need another try.

The describe step is often the hardest part. Teachers are used to jumping straight to causes, like “They didn’t read the directions.” The coach can gently redirect with a prompt such as “What do you see on the page?” That keeps the group grounded in what students did. It also makes the conversation feel safer, since no one’s teaching is on trial.

Teams also get better with practice. The first review may feel slow. By the third or fourth round, teachers know the steps, bring the right samples, and move to decisions faster.

How can a coach support teams looking at student work?

The coach keeps the process focused and safe. These coach moves help:

  • Co-plan the task. Use Student Evidence Analysis during Plan to choose a common task that shows progress toward the BIG Goal.
  • Model the protocol. Facilitate the first few rounds, then hand off roles like facilitator and timekeeper to team members.
  • Gather evidence during a Snapshot. A Snapshot is a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit. Look for the agreed move in action during Act.
  • Debrief and decide. Use Data Reflection to compare new student work to the starting point and choose the next Move.

School leaders can protect team time for this work and join a meeting to learn alongside teachers.

How do you run a team student work review step by step?

This sequence keeps the team focused from the first sample to the final decision.

The filled-in tool: Team Student Work Review ProtocolThe full issue as a PDF, with the tool, the Take Action steps, and the reflection prompts. Free with your email.
Get the download
  1. 1Set the BIG Goal
  2. 2Choose a common task
  3. 3Bring a range of samples
  4. 4Describe before explaining
  5. 5Name patterns in student thinking
  6. 6Agree on one next move
  7. 7Bring new evidence back
  8. The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download

Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.

This process centers on the REVIEW Teams Protocol, used in the Reflect step of a Team Coaching Sprint. It pairs with two PAR coaching strategies: Student Evidence Analysis during Plan and Data Reflection during Reflect. In the Simple Strategy Hub, each PAR strategy has its own strategy card and explainer video.

Where should a team start?

Start with one common task and one meeting. Set team norms first, so everyone feels safe sharing work. These PLC norms can help. To see how this fits into a full cycle, read about the Coaching Sprint.

Keep reading: What Student Work Tells You About Instruction and PLC Norms: 12 Examples and How to Set Them With Your Team.

Questions people ask

What is a critical friends group?

A critical friends group is a team of educators who meet regularly to look at student work and give each other feedback using a protocol. Many schools now use a looking-at-student-work protocol inside team coaching cycles. The goal stays the same: study evidence together and plan a next instructional step.

What is a looking at student work protocol?

A looking at student work protocol is a structured process teams follow to review student samples. Teachers describe what they see, name patterns in student thinking, and agree on next steps. The structure keeps conversation on evidence and helps every team member contribute, so meetings end with a clear plan.

How often should teacher teams look at student work?

Teacher teams should look at student work every two to three weeks, and weekly works well during a coaching cycle. Regular reviews let teams check whether a new instructional move is helping students. Short, frequent reviews of a common task tend to be more useful than occasional long sessions.

What student work should teams bring to a review?

Teams should bring work from a common task that connects to their goal, like an exit ticket, a short written response, or a problem set. Each teacher can bring a small range of samples, such as strong, partial, and missed. Using the same task makes patterns across classrooms easier to see.

How do coaches facilitate looking at student work in a PLC?

Coaches facilitate by choosing a common task with the team, following a clear protocol, and keeping talk focused on evidence. At first the coach leads each step. Over time, team members take on roles like facilitator and timekeeper. The coach makes sure every meeting ends with one agreed next move.

What is the REVIEW Teams Protocol?

The REVIEW Teams Protocol is a structured process for reviewing evidence and student work, used in the Reflect step of a Team Coaching Sprint. It helps teams look at results, find patterns, and choose the next move. Coaches can also use it 1:1 with a single teacher during a Coaching Sprint.

Want more like this?

Get the Training or Grab the Tools

The Hub is the full buffet. The Resource Pass is grab and go.

Want the training?

The Simple Strategy Hub

Everything in one place: the PD, the strategies, the tools, and a community of coaches and leaders doing the same work.

  • Pick your path: Coach Development or Strengthen Instruction
  • A new 10-minute Simple Insights training every week
  • Foundational Learning: CoachPath, Coaching Sprints, and the S.I.M.P.L.E. Blueprint
  • The full strategy library, organized by the 13 Anchors, with training videos
  • Every tool and form, plus the #SimpleStrategySquad community
$27a month, or $270 a year
Join the Hub
Just need it grab and go?

The Resource Pass

Quick downloads, no training required. Pick what you need this month and go.

  • 6 downloads every 30 days
  • Coaching forms, planners, and PD resources
  • Strategy cards with the coach guide and how-to ebook
  • Every new resource the week it comes out
  • Keep everything you download
$12a month, or $120 a year
Get the Pass

Leading a school or district? Bring this training to your teamWant to learn live? See upcoming workshops

FREE INSIGHTS!

Free bite-sized PD for instructional coaches and school leaders, delivered weekly to your inbox with Simple Insights.