Today we’re going to talk about diagnostic assessment, but first, a short video. There is a three-minute clip of graduates of MIT, some of the brightest students in the world, being asked about something basic and struggling to explain it. What does that make you think about?
These are supposed to be some of the most brilliant humans on the planet, and yet they have very little understanding of something so basic. To me, this video demonstrates how powerful our students’ misconceptions are in their learning.
Every student has had experiences both in and out of the classroom that influence the way that they think. Unless we can uncover these misconceptions, we may be able to teach our students some new content, but we’ll never be able to correct their fundamental understanding of big concepts. Diagnostic assessment is how we uncover them before the unit starts, when there is still time to do something about it.
What is a diagnostic assessment?
A diagnostic assessment is an assessment given before instruction to find out what students already know, what prerequisite skills they are missing, and how they are thinking about the concepts you are about to teach. It is never graded, because students haven’t learned the material yet. Its only job is to give you and your students information.
You should always give a diagnostic assessment at the beginning of the school year. Your beginning-of-year assessment will cover everything that your students should learn that year and maybe some of what they should have learned in the previous year. This assessment will serve as a benchmark so that you can measure growth throughout the year.
It’s also a good idea to give a diagnostic assessment for each individual unit. These will give you more insight into how students are thinking about the topic and how to form groups for small group instruction.
Not all diagnostic assessments need to be tests. Here are some alternative formats that work well:
- Poll Everywhere surveys integrate with Google Slides and let students anonymously vote on content questions or type their ideas in response to an open-ended question.
- Anticipation guides have a series of statements (some true, some misconceptions) that students rate as true or false. You’ll return later to reflect on the statements.
- Pre-writes, brain dumps, and journals are opportunities for students to respond to a few prompting questions or list everything they know about the topic.
- KWL (Know, Wonder, Learn) charts help you understand students’ prior knowledge and interests.
- On a graffiti wall you can post your essential questions for the unit and have students add their own questions or their thoughts about the questions.
Why diagnostic assessment changes what happens in classrooms
Diagnostic assessment is a critical component of teaching, and there are so many reasons to use it. It helps us uncover gaps in our students’ knowledge, understand how students are thinking about concepts we are about to teach, and see what students already know so that we can build on it. It tells us where remediation is necessary, how to separate students into groups for small group instruction, how to differentiate, and how to measure growth over time.
Without it, we teach the unit we planned to the class we imagined. With it, we teach the unit the students in front of us need. A misconception that goes unnoticed in September is still there in May, sitting underneath everything built on top of it, which is exactly what the MIT video shows.
If you work with an instructional coach, the diagnostic data is also the best starting point for a Coaching Sprint (coaching cycle). A coach can look at the items students missed, help you decide which gap to teach first, and then use a Snapshot, a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit, to watch how the small groups you formed from the data are working.
How do you create a diagnostic assessment?
The first step in crafting a diagnostic assessment is to think about what you want students to be able to do at the end of learning, and your content standards are where to look. One good source of questions is your state assessment, and these “end goal” questions will make up the majority of the assessment. Next, create questions that assess students’ prerequisite knowledge, because identifying foundational holes lets you fill in the gaps and correct them quickly. Third, create questions that let you see into students’ ways of thinking: items that test common misconceptions, or open-ended questions that ask students to explain their trains of thought. As you craft all of these items, make sure each question is aligned with a specific skill or learning objective, since alignment makes it much easier to form groups or plan remediation. Then decide how you will use the data. Keep the score out of your grade book, but track how students did and show them their work with feedback, so both of you can see what they need to learn and measure growth over time. The eight steps below are the order I work in. The full steps, with the tool, are in the download.
- 1Start with the end-goal standards
- 2Pull questions from state assessments
- 3Add prerequisite knowledge questions
- 4Write questions that reveal thinking
- 5Align every item to a skill
- 6Keep the score out of the grade book
- 7Show students their work with feedback
- 8Use the data to form groups
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
Find the misconception before you teach on top of it
The students in the video were brilliant, and nobody had ever checked what they believed before adding more. Give the diagnostic, read it closely, and let what you find shape the first week of the unit. You and your students will both know exactly where the learning starts.
Keep reading: What Student Work Tells You About Instruction and Is It a Tier 1 Problem or an Intervention Need?.
Questions people ask
What is a diagnostic assessment?
A diagnostic assessment is given before instruction to find out what students already know, what prerequisite skills they are missing, and what misconceptions they hold about the concepts you are about to teach. It is never graded, because students have not learned the material yet.
When should teachers give a diagnostic assessment?
Give one at the beginning of the school year covering everything students should learn that year, which becomes a benchmark for growth. Then give a shorter one before each unit to see how students are thinking about that topic and to form small groups.
What should a diagnostic assessment include?
Mostly end-goal questions drawn from your standards and state assessments, plus questions that check prerequisite knowledge and questions that reveal common misconceptions or ask students to explain their thinking. Every item should align to a specific skill so grouping and remediation are easy.
