Get Simple Insights Every Week LOGIN CONTACT
Simply Coaching
All Insights

Strengthening Tier 1 · Issue 7 · Feb 26, 2019

Helping Teachers Plan What Happens at the Small Group Table

Start with the learning target and student evidence, plan what happens at the table, and decide what comes next.

When a teacher says they want to start small groups, the first question is usually how many groups and which stations. That’s where a lot of small group time goes sideways. The planning energy goes into rotations and materials, and the teacher sits down at the table without a clear answer to the most important question: what am I teaching these students today?

Precision is what makes small group time worth taking. A note like “these students are low in math” gives the teacher nothing to teach. “These four students can identify equivalent fractions with models but can’t explain why the fractions are equivalent” gives them a target, a lesson, and a way to check.

This issue walks through how a coach helps a teacher plan that kind of small group, from the target to the check. Before the first group meets, students also need to learn the routines; Issue 10 lays out a 10-day launch plan. Issue 8 goes deeper on analyzing evidence and adjusting groups over time.

What goes into planning small group instruction?

Planning starts with the learning, and the logistics come last. Before anyone talks about stations, a coach and teacher can work through three questions together.

What should students understand or be able to do? Name the learning target from the current unit in the school’s curriculum. Small group time supports grade-level learning, so the target comes from what the class is working on now.

What does the student evidence show? Look at a recent exit ticket, a set of work samples, or notes from a lesson and name the specific error, misconception, or unfinished learning. “Struggling with fractions” is too broad to plan from. “Can find equivalent fractions with models but can’t explain why they’re equivalent” is something a teacher can teach in one sitting.

Which students need the same instructional response? That’s the group. It’s temporary and built around one specific need, so students move in and out as the evidence changes. A student who shows they’ve got it after two days leaves the group, and a student who surfaces the same need next week joins it.

What does the teacher teach at the table?

This is the part most small group plans skip, and it’s where the learning happens. A 10 to 20 minute session can follow a simple arc, and if your school uses gradual release, it’s I Do, We Do, You Do at a smaller scale.

  1. Explain it a new way. Students in the group already heard the whole-class lesson, so the teacher plans a different entry point: a new representation, a simpler example, or a direct look at the misconception.
  2. Model the thinking. The teacher thinks aloud through one problem, naming each decision. For the fractions group, that might sound like “I see the same amount shaded, so I’m going to check whether the whole is split into equal parts.”
  3. Guide the practice. Students work a few problems together with the teacher prompting, correcting, and giving feedback in the moment.
  4. Have them try it alone. Each student completes one or two problems on their own while the teacher watches.
  5. Check. One quick task at the end shows whether each student can do what the target asks, without help.

Supports like a visual model, a sentence frame for the explanation, or a worked example can help students get started. Plan for those supports to come off as students show they can work without them.

What is the rest of the class doing?

Start with one targeted group. A teacher new to small groups can begin with one group at the table and the rest of the class working steadily for 15 minutes, which is all it takes to teach one group well.

The best work for the rest of the room is purposeful practice of learning that’s already been taught: a practice set from the current unit, independent reading with a clear response task, or a review of last week’s skill. Students should know how to do it without asking, and it should be work they can finish.

Two things keep it running:

  • Clear expectations. Students know what to do, what to do when they’re stuck, and what to do when they finish. Practice the routine as a whole class before the first group meets.
  • Accountability. Something gets turned in, checked, or shared, so the work counts and students treat it that way.

Once one group runs smoothly, the teacher can add a second group or a second type of independent work.

How can an instructional coach support small group instruction?

The coach has a role at every point in the plan.

  • Examine work together. Sit with the teacher and a stack of student work and name the specific need. This is often the conversation that turns “my low group” into a teachable target.
  • Co-plan the teaching. Work out the new explanation, the think-aloud, the practice problems, and the check before the session.
  • Rehearse or model. Practice the think-aloud together, or the coach models the first session while the teacher watches.
  • Gather evidence. During a Snapshot, a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit, the coach watches the table: what students say, what they get right on the check, and whether the rest of the room keeps working.
  • Reflect and decide. Debrief with the teacher using the check results and decide together what happens next for the group.

If small groups are a teacher’s focus, this sequence fits naturally inside a Coaching Sprint (coaching cycle).

How do you plan small group instruction step by step?

The six steps below are the planning sequence a coach and teacher can walk through together, from the target to the check.

The filled-in tool: Small Group Planning SheetThe full issue as a PDF, with the tool, the Take Action steps, and the reflection prompts. Free with your email.
Get the download
  1. 1Identify the learning target
  2. 2Examine student evidence
  3. 3Form a temporary group
  4. 4Plan the teaching: explain, model, guide, try alone
  5. 5Prepare the rest of the class
  6. 6Check and adjust
  7. The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download

Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.

These six steps are how teachers use Targeted Small Group Instruction, one of the Simple Strategies under Anchor 11, Differentiation and Scaffolding. The strategy card in the Simple Strategy Hub walks teachers through the strategy, and its coach guide gives you the look-fors to use during a Snapshot. It pairs with Scaffold and Fade for planning the supports students use at the table.

Check and decide what comes next

The session isn’t done until the teacher knows where each student landed. The check at the end of the session drives one of three decisions:

  • Continue. Students are closer but not there yet. Meet again tomorrow with the same target and a fresh set of problems.
  • Adjust. The approach didn’t land. Try a different explanation or model, or narrow the target.
  • Release. Students can do it on their own. They rejoin the class, and the teacher watches for the skill in whole-group work.

That decision is the best part of the debrief, and it’s where the coach and teacher see small group time paying off in student learning.

Keep reading: Teach the Routines First: A 10-Day Plan for Launching Small Groups and Guided Groups or Small Groups? Helping Teachers Choose.

Questions people ask

How do you plan small group instruction?

Plan small group instruction by starting with a learning target from the current unit and recent student evidence. Form a temporary group around one specific need, plan what the teacher will explain, model, and guide, prepare familiar practice for the rest of the class, and end the session with a quick check that decides what happens next.

What should the teacher teach during small group instruction?

During small group instruction, the teacher reteaches one specific skill in 10 to 20 minutes: a new explanation, a modeled think-aloud, guided practice with in-the-moment feedback, a short independent try, and a quick check. In schools that use gradual release, this is I Do, We Do, You Do at a smaller scale.

What should the rest of the class do during small groups?

While the teacher works with a small group, the rest of the class should do purposeful practice of learning that's already been taught, like a practice set from the current unit. Students need clear expectations for what to do when stuck or finished, plus something that gets turned in or checked so the work counts.

How many students should be in a small group?

Most small groups work best with about three to six students who share the same specific learning need. The need decides the size. If only two students need the reteach, teach two. If ten students need it, the skill may call for a whole-class reteach the next day.

How long should small group instruction last?

Small group instruction usually lasts 10 to 20 minutes per group, enough time for a new explanation, modeling, guided practice, a short independent try, and a check. Younger students and teachers new to small groups often do best at the shorter end, adding time as routines and stamina build.

How often should small groups change?

Small groups should change as often as student evidence says they should. Groups are temporary and built around one specific need, so a student leaves once they can show the skill on their own, and a new student joins when the same need shows up in their work. Check results after each session drive those moves.

How can an instructional coach support small group instruction?

An instructional coach supports small group instruction by examining student work with the teacher to name the specific need, co-planning the teaching, rehearsing or modeling a session, and gathering evidence during a short classroom visit. The coach and teacher then debrief using the check results and decide whether to continue, adjust, or release the group.

Want more like this?

Get the Training or Grab the Tools

The Hub is the full buffet. The Resource Pass is grab and go.

Want the training?

The Simple Strategy Hub

Everything in one place: the PD, the strategies, the tools, and a community of coaches and leaders doing the same work.

  • Pick your path: Coach Development or Strengthen Instruction
  • A new 10-minute Simple Insights training every week
  • Foundational Learning: CoachPath, Coaching Sprints, and the S.I.M.P.L.E. Blueprint
  • The full strategy library, organized by the 13 Anchors, with training videos
  • Every tool and form, plus the #SimpleStrategySquad community
$27a month, or $270 a year
Join the Hub
Just need it grab and go?

The Resource Pass

Quick downloads, no training required. Pick what you need this month and go.

  • 6 downloads every 30 days
  • Coaching forms, planners, and PD resources
  • Strategy cards with the coach guide and how-to ebook
  • Every new resource the week it comes out
  • Keep everything you download
$12a month, or $120 a year
Get the Pass

Want to learn live? See upcoming workshopsLeading a school or district? Bring this training to your team

FREE INSIGHTS!

Free bite-sized PD for instructional coaches and school leaders, delivered weekly to your inbox with Simple Insights.