After about five minutes of explaining how to divide fractions on the board I felt a palpable shift in the students’ energy. Eyes wandered. Pencils doodled. Chairs scratched the floor. I was losing them. It was time to shift to either guided or small group instruction.
Every good teacher can feel it, the moment when whole group instruction stops being effective. This is the moment when you have to get your students doing something. When we do small group or guided instruction we have the opportunity to get students practicing skills, and we gain the opportunity to work more closely with a few students at a time. The two models get used interchangeably in a lot of buildings, and they shouldn’t be, because they answer two different questions about your students. This issue walks through what each model is, where they overlap, where they differ, and what each one does for the students in front of you, so you can pick the right one for the moment you’re in.
What is small group instruction, and how is it different from guided instruction?
Both guided instruction and small group instruction involve separating your class into groups of three to six students. In both models, the teacher differentiates the activities and instruction for each group, choosing the resources and methods of practice that best suit each group’s needs. The teacher sits down with each group for 10 to 20 minutes. During this time the teacher might model a skill, reteach a strategy, or listen in on the group’s thinking as they read or work on an activity. While the teacher is meeting with one group, other groups engage in independent practice or hands-on activities that align with the learning target and with each group’s needs. Frequent formative and diagnostic assessment data is used to form groups in both models, and students move in and out of each group depending on their performance.
So what is the difference between the two models? You split the class into groups and you differentiate. Aren’t they the same? No, and the difference is simple.
- Groups for guided instruction are made based on each student’s overall achievement with the content: below, at, or above grade level. The resources given to each group are differentiated primarily based on depth of knowledge and difficulty. Each group works on the same skills at different levels.
- Groups for small group instruction are made based on a particular skill gap. The resources provided to each group target that specific skill in place of general practice.
Here’s an analogy that I like to use when thinking about the difference between the two models. Imagine that you are coaching a basketball camp where the athletes come with all different levels of ability and yet every player wants to leave the camp better than when they started. Guided instruction is like having the athletes with similar ability scrimmage against each other. In every scrimmage, the players are working on all their skills at once and they are evenly matched in competition. Small group instruction is like having students work on drills to improve upon a particular weakness. You might have one group working on passing drills, another practicing layups. Within each of the groups you could have the “best” player and the “worst” player working on the same skill.
In the classroom, the two models look like this. When you use guided reading, you group students based on their reading level, and each group practices reading with a different text while you listen in and coach them along the way. In guided math, every group works on the same topic with different levels of scaffolding and resources. If the class is learning about adding fractions, the lowest level group might use manipulatives and a multiplication table, while the highest level group works on more challenging problems or begins to solve word problems involving adding fractions. In small group reading instruction, you use assessment data to identify which specific skill to work on with each group and choose a text that lets students practice that one thing. The level of the text isn’t as relevant, because its purpose is to facilitate conversation and practice with the skill. In small group math instruction, one group might work on finding common denominators while another needs practice with multiplication tables. All groups are working toward the same content standard, and each one needs a different path for getting there.
Why flexible grouping changes what happens in classrooms
Using these models, I love that I’m able to give every student exactly what they need. The instruction takes students at their current level and provides them the resources, practice, and tools to progress, whatever their starting point. When students are in smaller groups they don’t feel isolated in their learning. They work with peers who need the same things that they do. This means that they are less embarrassed to pose questions and ask for help since the students in their group are likely facing the same challenges.
The fluidity of both models reinforces a growth mindset in your students. They don’t feel like they’re stuck in the slower group, and they don’t feel pressure to always be achieving the highest level. It’s okay to need a little extra practice, and that practice will pay off. When your coach visits during a Snapshot, a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit, one of the first things they’ll look for is how the groups were formed and whether the task in front of each group fits the data that put those students there.
How do you choose between guided and small group instruction?
The choice comes down to what your data is telling you. When students are spread across levels on the same skills, guided instruction lets you meet each level where it is. When the data shows specific gaps, a handful of students who can’t find a common denominator and another handful who stall on multiplication facts, small group instruction lets you target the gap directly. The steps below walk you through that decision and into your first round of groups. The full steps, with the Grouping Decision Guide, are in the download.
- 1Name the learning target
- 2Review your latest assessment data
- 3Decide: overall level or skill gap
- 4Form groups of three to six
- 5Choose resources for each group
- 6Plan your 10 to 20 minute teacher time
- 7Set independent activities for other groups
- 8Re-sort groups after the next check
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
Pick the model the moment calls for
The next time you feel that shift in the room, you have two good options, and the data on your desk will tell you which one to use. Either way, your students get to work on exactly what they need, alongside peers who need it too.
Keep reading: Helping Teachers Plan What Happens at the Small Group Table and Using Student Data to Decide Who Comes to the Table.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between guided instruction and small group instruction?
Guided instruction groups students by overall achievement with the content, below, at, or above grade level, and every group works on the same skills at different levels of difficulty. Small group instruction groups students by a particular skill gap, so each group's resources target that one skill.
How big should groups be for small group instruction?
Both guided and small group instruction work with groups of three to six students. The teacher sits with each group for 10 to 20 minutes while the other groups work on independent practice or hands-on activities tied to the learning target.
How do you decide which students go in which group?
Use frequent formative and diagnostic assessment data to form the groups, and let students move in and out of groups as their performance changes. Flexible groups keep students from feeling stuck in a slower group and reinforce a growth mindset.
