Get Simple Insights Every Week LOGIN CONTACT
Simply Coaching
All Insights

Strengthening Tier 1 · Issue 2 · Mar 6, 2018

Why Teachers Skip the We Do and How Coaches Can Help

How coaches help teachers plan each phase of I Do, We Do, You Do so students do the thinking before working alone.

You walk into a sixth-grade math class halfway through the lesson. The teacher modeled two problems at the board, and now students are working alone on a page of twenty. Half the room has a hand up.

Later in the week, you visit again. This time the teacher says, “Let’s do this one together,” and then solves every step while students copy it down. It looks like a We Do, but the students aren’t doing the thinking.

These are the two most common gradual release problems coaches see. The good news is that both are fixable with a little planning and a clear picture of what each phase should sound like.

What is gradual release of responsibility?

Gradual release of responsibility is a way to structure a lesson so the thinking moves from the teacher to the students over time. Most teachers know it as I Do, We Do, You Do.

  • I Do: The teacher models the skill and thinks aloud.
  • We Do: Students try it with support while the teacher prompts and checks.
  • You Do: Students practice on their own while the teacher monitors.

The release is gradual for a reason. Students need enough guided practice to be successful before they work alone. Explicit instruction like this is well supported by research, especially for new or complex skills.

What does gradual release look like in a classroom?

Here’s a third-grade lesson on finding the main idea.

  • I Do: The teacher reads a short paragraph aloud and thinks out loud: “Most of these sentences are about how bees help plants. That sounds like the main idea.”
  • We Do: The class reads a second paragraph. Partners talk about what most sentences are about. The teacher calls on a few pairs and asks them to explain their thinking.
  • We Do again: Students try a third paragraph on whiteboards. The teacher scans the boards and pulls a few students who missed it for a quick reteach.
  • You Do: Students find the main idea in two new paragraphs on their own.

Notice the We Do happens more than once. That’s where most of the learning happens, and it’s the phase that gets cut first when time runs short.

How can an instructional coach support gradual release?

Gradual release makes a great focus for a Coaching Sprint (coaching cycle) because the phases are easy to see and easy to plan. These coach moves help:

  • Co-plan each phase. Look at an upcoming lesson together. Write what the teacher will say in the I Do, what students will do in the We Do, and how the teacher will check before the You Do.
  • Script the think aloud. Many I Do segments show the steps but skip the thinking. Help the teacher write two or three sentences that name the decisions an expert makes.
  • Rehearse or model the We Do. Practice prompts that hand the work to students, like “What should we do first? Tell your partner.” Or model a We Do in the classroom while the teacher watches.
  • Gather evidence during a Snapshot. A Snapshot is a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit. Time each phase and write down who is doing the thinking in the We Do: the teacher or the students.
  • Debrief and decide the next step. Share the timing and the quotes you collected. Choose one change, such as adding a quick check for understanding before students work alone.

The same structure works at the small group table. Planning Small Group Instruction shows how a mini I Do, We Do, You Do fits into a 15-minute group.

How do you plan a gradual release lesson step by step?

Use these steps when co-planning a lesson with a teacher.

The filled-in tool: Gradual Release Lesson Look-For GuideThe full issue as a PDF, with the tool, the Take Action steps, and the reflection prompts. Free with your email.
Get the download
  1. 1Name the skill and success criteria
  2. 2Script a short think aloud for I Do
  3. 3Plan a worked example students can reference
  4. 4Hand the thinking to students in We Do
  5. 5Check understanding before releasing students
  6. 6Monitor and support during You Do
  7. The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download

Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.

These steps are how teachers use Modeling and Think Alouds, Worked Examples, and Guided Practice, three of the Simple Strategies under Anchor 05, Explicit Instruction and Gradual Release. In the Simple Strategy Hub, each strategy card walks teachers through the move, and the coach guide gives you the look-fors to use during a Snapshot.

What’s the next move?

Start with one lesson and plan the We Do first. Strong guided practice also sets students up for independent work at stations, so pair this with our 10-day small group launch plan.

Keep reading: Helping Teachers Plan What Happens at the Small Group Table and Teach the Routines First: A 10-Day Plan for Launching Small Groups.

Questions people ask

What is gradual release of responsibility?

Gradual release of responsibility is a lesson structure that moves the thinking from the teacher to the students in stages. The teacher models (I Do), students practice with support (We Do), and students work independently (You Do). Gradual release is a core part of explicit instruction for new or complex skills.

What does I Do, We Do, You Do mean?

I Do, We Do, You Do is the everyday name for gradual release of responsibility. In I Do, the teacher models and thinks aloud. In We Do, students try the skill with prompts and feedback. In You Do, students practice on their own while the teacher monitors and supports.

What is the most common mistake with gradual release?

The most common gradual release mistake is skipping or shortening the We Do. Lessons jump from teacher modeling straight to independent work, or the teacher does all the solving during the We Do. Students need guided practice where they do the thinking themselves before they work alone.

How long should each part of I Do, We Do, You Do take?

There's no fixed time for each part of I Do, We Do, You Do. A common guide is a short I Do of 5 to 10 minutes, a longer We Do, and a You Do that starts once most students show they're ready. The We Do often needs the most time.

How can an instructional coach help a teacher with gradual release?

An instructional coach helps a teacher with gradual release by co-planning each phase, scripting think alouds, rehearsing We Do prompts, and timing each phase during a short classroom visit. The coach and teacher then debrief the evidence and choose one adjustment to make in the next lesson.

What is a think aloud in teaching?

A think aloud is when the teacher says their thinking out loud while modeling a skill. The teacher names the decisions an expert makes, like checking whether an answer makes sense. Think alouds make invisible thinking visible for students and are a key part of the I Do phase of gradual release.

Want more like this?

Get the Training or Grab the Tools

The Hub is the full buffet. The Resource Pass is grab and go.

Want the training?

The Simple Strategy Hub

Everything in one place: the PD, the strategies, the tools, and a community of coaches and leaders doing the same work.

  • Pick your path: Coach Development or Strengthen Instruction
  • A new 10-minute Simple Insights training every week
  • Foundational Learning: CoachPath, Coaching Sprints, and the S.I.M.P.L.E. Blueprint
  • The full strategy library, organized by the 13 Anchors, with training videos
  • Every tool and form, plus the #SimpleStrategySquad community
$27a month, or $270 a year
Join the Hub
Just need it grab and go?

The Resource Pass

Quick downloads, no training required. Pick what you need this month and go.

  • 6 downloads every 30 days
  • Coaching forms, planners, and PD resources
  • Strategy cards with the coach guide and how-to ebook
  • Every new resource the week it comes out
  • Keep everything you download
$12a month, or $120 a year
Get the Pass

Leading a school or district? Bring this training to your teamWant to learn live? See upcoming workshops

FREE INSIGHTS!

Free bite-sized PD for instructional coaches and school leaders, delivered weekly to your inbox with Simple Insights.