There was a season in my coaching work when I could walk away from a conversation feeling like it had gone well and still come back into the classroom later and see very little change. The teacher and I had talked, reflected, and had named what students did and did not do. We had even shared ideas for what could happen next. Nothing about the conversation felt wrong. In fact, many of those conversations felt strong, supportive, thoughtful, and full of possibility.
But when I looked at the instruction, I had to tell myself the truth. A conversation can feel productive and still not move practice.
That was a hard realization for me because I value the relational side of coaching. I believe in listening and asking strong questions. I still believe all of that. But over time, I started to see that some of my coaching conversations were stopping too soon. We were getting to awareness but not always getting to action.
That is when I stopped seeing the conversation itself as the finish line and started seeing it as the bridge. The goal was to help that teacher leave with greater clarity about what to do next, how to do it, and the why behind the what. For me, that work came down to three shifts.
What are the three shifts that make a coaching conversation impactful?
The first shift is moving from reflection to strategy. Reflection is important, and I will never tell coaches to stop reflecting with teachers. But reflection by itself can stay too broad. The teacher can say students were disengaged and the coach agrees, and if it ends there, the teacher leaves with a feeling in place of a move. I had to learn how to help the teacher move from “My students were not fully engaged” to “What strategy could help students engage more actively in this part of the lesson?” One stays at the level of observation. The other begins to move toward instructional design.
The second shift is moving from ideas to implementation. Many coaching conversations end right at the point where they start sounding good. The coach shares a strategy, both people agree it would help, and the teacher walks back into a busy classroom where that idea never becomes part of instruction. It is one thing to say, “You could use turn and talk here.” It is another thing to say, “After you model the first example, stop and have students explain the process to a partner using one sentence stem, then bring them back and listen for misconceptions before you move on.” That is a plan.
The third shift is moving from reflection to next steps. By the end of the conversation, the teacher should feel clear on what they are trying next, what they are paying attention to, and what the next coaching touchpoint is going to build on. Even if the next step is small, it should be specific enough that the teacher can carry it into instruction and the coach can come back and build on it.
Most coaches are having these conversations in a short window between classes, so I think about what a strong twenty-minute conversation looks like. In the first few minutes, I connect with the teacher as a person, because the relationship is part of the work. Then I move into reflection and ask what stood out or where momentum dropped. This is where the old version of my coaching often stopped. Now I listen for the strategy question hiding underneath the reflection and make the turn: “If we wanted students to engage more actively in that moment, what strategy might support that?” From there we talk through what it would look like in their lesson, and the teacher leaves with a next step that feels clear and doable.
Why these shifts change what happens in classrooms
The impact shows up after the conversation ends. Imagine a teacher and coach are debriefing a lesson where students struggled to explain their thinking. In a more general conversation, they might talk about engagement and agree that students need to participate more, and the teacher may leave without a clear sense of what to do differently.
When the coach uses these three shifts, the conversation narrows to one instructional move: students needed a structured opportunity to explain their thinking after the model. They decide that after the teacher models the first problem, students will turn to a partner and explain their thinking using a sentence stem, and the teacher will pause, listen in, and decide whether to move forward or reteach.
Now the teacher is leaving with a planned move for the very next lesson, and when the coach comes back, there is something concrete to look for. The conversation led to a change in instruction, and that change created a better opportunity for students to think, respond, and learn.
How do you structure a coaching conversation that leads to action?
You do not need a rigid script, but you do need a flow that moves the conversation forward. The five steps below follow the same cadence I use in a twenty-minute conversation.
- 1Connect with intention
- 2Reflect on the lesson
- 3Narrow the focus to a strategy
- 4Make implementation concrete
- 5End with a clear next step
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
The conversation is the bridge
You are never trying to force the conversation. You are guiding it with more intention: begin with connection, move into reflection, narrow to strategy, talk through implementation, and end with a next step. That simple flow decides whether the conversation stays in the space of ideas or moves into classroom action.
Watch: Why Coaching Conversations Do Not Always Change Classroom Instruction
Nicole talked through this topic on Insights Live, our show on YouTube.
Read the transcript
Hey, hey coaches. Welcome, welcome, welcome, welcome tonight. I was over here playing with my StreamYard trying to figure it out. So, sorry about that. If you are tuning in live, please put in the chat where you are tuning in from and what it is that you are coaching. That would be great.
Or your position or whatever. Just something. Say hi to me. Say what’s up. And tonight we’re going to talk about coaching conversations, right? And why we need to do more than just coaching conversations.
So let me know who is in the chat with me. I see some people are here. So I just want to give you and I know it’s a delay. Let me see if I could pull this my notes up. I had them up a second ago. All right.
Oh, man. Okay. Well, let’s make it easy. Let’s make it quick tonight. So, here’s the thing. We talk about coaching conversations and we talk about how coaching is more than that, right?
And so there are three things and I feel like there are three shifts that need to happen in order for coaching to what do I say for us to move from just having coaching conversations. So we talk about coaching conversations a lot in coaching, right? That’s like a big thing. But I want to really say that we need to move from coaching conversations to something else because I feel like coaching conversations are not enough. What happens when we are in a coaching conversation, right? We are asking questions, we’re reflecting with the teacher and then we’re introducing ideas and all of those are part of, you know, coaching, right?
So, we have that coaching conversation. We want people to feel good. We’re building trust with them, all of those things. But there is a challenge in the coaching conversations that we’re having because things are not happening in the classroom. So the conversations are not creating impact in our classrooms and that is becoming a struggle. Especially now when we’re looking at budgets and we’re look we’re looking at you know different things like that where coaches may have to defend their position or leaders are looking for how coaching aligns to student learning or even supporting teachers, right?
And so the challenge is that the coaching conversations we’re having really need to be strategy conversations. And when I say when I say that those coaching conversations that we’re having, I’m just saying that they just lack strategy. Like again, we’re asking questions, we’re reflecting with teachers, and we’re introducing ideas, but we’re not talking about strategy, and we’re not talking about implementation, right? So coaching conversations in my book, they really build understanding, right? They built that reflection and all of that, but strategy conversations lead to actual implementation. And so I think that there are three shifts that move coaching conversations into strategy conversations if that makes sense.
And then our first shift is to move from reflection to identifying the instructional move. So many times we often stop at reflection. So we ask questions like what worked, what did not work and then like what are students struggling with which those are great conversation I mean great questions to ask but reflection alone just doesn’t change that instruction right so we have to now take that next step and so we need to identify the instructional move that is where the conversation starts to shift right so we start with coaching and then we move into strategy and so the questions that we like what strategies will we use like what instructional move will support students and then what will be different next time. So those are the kind of questions. So when teachers leave, they leave with an instructional move that’s planned out, something concrete, something that they can implement right away, right? Instead of saying like we need more engagement, we leave you end the conversation or at the end of that conversation we are talking about implementing think pair share during you know our practice time.
So that is us moving from reflection to strategy. All right. So that is one of the biggest shifts that you know we need to with I guess the first shift that we need to talk about. So our second shift is move from naming a strategy to actually building an implementation plan. Right? So that’s the second shift where we identify a strategy and then we talk about it.
We may just say, “Hey, that’s a good strategy.” Or a coach makes the suggestion because I’ve been talking with coaches lately and they’re like, “Yeah, I’ve made that suggestion with teachers all the time, right? Like, hey, let’s try some small groups. Let’s maybe you want to implement checks for understanding or you want to try some cold calling, right? That’s just naming the strategy. But it’s not enough for us to just name a strategy that we’re going to implement or unpack the standard.”
Like we have to have an implementation plan because we need to know will this when will this happen? We need to answer questions like what will it look like? What will I say as the teacher? That is an implementation plan. And so when we’re sitting down and we having these conversations, we cannot just only just reflect. We have to go again to that next step of talking about implementation.
So some of our questions should really focus on like where in the lesson will this happen? How long will it take? What will students do? What success? What does success look like? A lot of times in coaching conversations or when we start planning and talking with teachers, doing that co-planning, co you know, really talking about what’s going to happen in the classroom because sometimes we do get there.
We don’t ever talk about what does success look like, right? What is the endgame? We do a lot of backwards design in our work, right? We unpack that standard. We look at the unit test and based on the unit test, we then u map out the lessons, right? So that’s one of the biggest things.
We need to like help teachers to visualize that implementation and then we can have them to you know actually practice it with us. Right? So that’s that’s one thing we want teachers to see it but we want them to implement it as well. And so that’s where we in our shift three we move from strategy planning to the next coaching move. Right? That’s our final shift.
So we can’t just stop at planning. We can’t just stop at implementation planning. We have to define what that next move is. So we try to think about when will you try this? You ask that question or can I come in and support? How can I come in and support?
Can we model? This is where you now dig into your coaching strategy bag, right? Into your coaching playbook and you identify your strategies, right? So you have your strategy notebook. I call that your strategy notebook. That’s your instructional strategies.
And in your coaching playbook, you have your coaching strategies. All right? And so then you’re going to pull out your coaching strategies and you’re going to say, “Hey, do we co-e? Do I model? Like what are some of the things that I can do to support them?” All right?
Because what we want to do is take the coaching from just having coaching conversations to actually continuing in the classroom, right? So we start at that conversation level then we start thinking about strategy right we have those strategy conversations and then we move into our classroom impact that’s when we design our coaching moves where we talk about those coaching strategies so when I talk about simple strategy coaching I’m not just talking about I talk about instructional strategies helping teachers to implement instructional strategies learn pedigogy unpack standards like all of those things, but I’m also telling you about how to utilize coaching strategies in order to support that teacher and to get all of that done. Okay? So, it’s both it’s both of those type of strategy coaching in order to make an impact. All right? So, we want to create some accountability and some support for teachers.
That is like the biggest piece to the puzzle. All right. So when I talk about this, I just want to reiterate my three shifts, right? Coaching conversations build understanding, but strategy conversations build implementation and implementation leads to impact. I’ll say that again. Coaching conversations build understanding, right?
Because that’s our reflection. What happened in the classroom? What do you think? All of that. And then we move from coaching conversations now to strategy conversations where we build implementation, right? That’s where we’re talking about our implementation plan.
We identify one of the structural strategies. We talk about what that lesson plan is. We may even use time mapping. All of that builds our implementation plan. And then we assist or support the teacher in actually implementing the plan. And that implementation leads to impact.
And so we combine our coaching conversations with strategy conversations. That is how we get instruction to change. Excuse me. That is how we get instruction to change. Any questions from anyone out there? All right.
So, those are my three points tonight. And I want you to really think about ways in which you could get this done, right? Think about a way and a process in which you can start to, you know, identify instructional moves. Like you could really think about your coaching conversations right now and what you are doing with your conversations and how they are flowing and what’s happening with them in your coaching conversations and how you could shift from that coaching reflection right you know what worked what did not work where did we see students struggle those are all important I don’t want to tell you that they’re not important they’re very important right that’s that foundation Now you want to actually implement that strategy. Talk about that strategy. Then you want to move that strategy talking about it to building a plan, right?
So when will this happen? What would it look like? What would I say? That’s using time mapping and planning. So you’re going to co-plan together, right? What does it look like?
What does it sound like in the classroom? And then you’re going to talk about your coaching moves. So like what’s going to happen when they start to implement? How are you going to support the implementation of that? Are you going to just observe, do video coaching? Are you going to do in the- moment coaching?
Are you going to co- teach co-plan? Like what is it of that coaching move that you are going to do to bring it all together? So, I’m going to give you three questions that I want you to if you’re watching the replay, you’re going to pause this. If you’re watching it live, you’re going to rewatch this. Or if you’re taking notes right now as we are talking. These are the three questions that you are going to answer when you are done with your coaching strategy conversation.
So you want to say did we identify the instructional move? Did we build the implementation plan? And did we define the next coaching move? Okay? Because when these three things happen, that is how we move beyond coaching conversations. That’s how we move into impact.
So the whole goal is to move coaching conversations into classroom impact. Okay, that is the goal. Oh, Nicole said I’m going to start titling here. I got to bring you up. I am going to start titling meetings strategy conversations. Yep, that is amazing because that’s what we really need to do.
We need to really start doing our strategy coaching. We really need to start just moving from classroom conversation into actual impact. And the only way we move it from classroom conversation to classroom impact is to actually talk about it, plan it, and do it and support the implementation of it. Because so many times there are so many teachers coaches that I have that I’m talking to on a regular basis and their biggest thing is hey I’m giving that to the teacher and they didn’t do anything with it or we had the conversation and they’re just not there is no transition of it from conversation to implementation and so because of that we have to then become a little bit more supportive in helping them and it’s the way in which we have the conversation Right? So, we can ask those questions, the reflection questions. We can get them we can ask the reflection questions to get them to see where the problem is and all of that.
I’m not saying don’t do any of that. I’m saying do that plus then talk about how you going to solve it, then plan how you’re going to solve it because really it’s strategy meetings, right? I call I call my I love to call my sessions like war room meetings, right? This the war room. This is where we coming in and we are you know deciding on our plan on our strategy and how we’re going to go in and teach these babies right so that is what I think about it and that’s how I think about this process okay so this is a short one tonight I wanted to keep it short and sweet because I wanted to make sure that you knew these are the three things that needed to happen and that is how it goes there are a couple of things that if you are looking for more support, I mean, you want to learn more about building your coaching playbook, please join us at the simply coaching summit. That’s www.
simplycoachingsummit. com. Make sure that you join us for there. If you are looking for any other strategies or you’re looking for some support, I don’t know, in your district or anything like that, then you can just email us at hello@simplycoaching. co and just ask for me, Nicole, address it to me. And then we can get you on the calendar for a strategy coaching call meeting where we could sit down and figure out a strategy on how to support instructional coaches in your district and build that strategy coaching with you all.
Well, I wanted to keep it short and sweet tonight. So, I hope those three points help you. Again, if you have any questions, email me hello@simplycoaching. co. Have a good night, y’all.
This transcript comes from the live session and has been lightly cleaned up.
Keep reading: Giving Feedback a Teacher Can Act On and Moving From Obstacles to Opportunities in Coaching Conversations.
Questions people ask
Why do coaching conversations fail to change instruction?
Many conversations stop at awareness. The teacher and coach reflect on what happened and agree students need more, but nobody names a specific strategy, works through how it will look in the lesson, or sets a clear next step.
What are the three shifts that make coaching conversations more impactful?
Move from reflection to strategy, from ideas to implementation, and from reflection to next steps. Each shift helps the teacher leave with a planned move they can use in the very next lesson.
What does a twenty-minute coaching conversation look like?
Connect with the teacher as a person, give them space to reflect on the lesson, narrow the focus to one strategy, talk through exactly how it will look with their students, and end with one clear, doable next step.
