An important first step in planning professional development is assessing and building a culture of learning at your school. I once worked in a building where staff morale was very low and teachers’ interest in growth and improvement felt nonexistent. Although the occasional teacher pushed himself to be better, as a whole, each team seemed stuck in their routines.
When I tried to implement the PLC cycle in that building, it crashed and burned because no one felt safe exposing their vulnerabilities in teaching. Everyone wanted to present themselves as being perfect, and if the data suggested otherwise, a myriad of excuses and defenses ran the conversation.
That experience taught me to check the culture before I plan the learning. A strong PD calendar dropped into a building that isn’t ready to learn goes nowhere. So before you plan a single session, take stock of the eight qualities below, and if the culture needs work, start there.
What does a culture of learning look like in a school?
Eight qualities separate a culture that is ripe for professional learning from one that is toxic to it. Each one below pairs a sign that the culture is toxic with a sign that it is ready.
- Growth mindset. Teachers, administrators, and students all need one for professional learning to occur. Toxic: “I don’t need to change, this is how I’ve always done it and it has worked.” Ripe: “I know these students can do it. I just need to figure out what they need.”
- Teachers take ownership. When teachers own their roles, they take responsibility for improving. Toxic: “If the students just tried harder, my teaching would be effective.” Ripe: “That lesson didn’t go well. What can I try tomorrow to readdress it?”
- Avenues for collaboration. PD is more effective when teachers are willing and able to work together. Toxic: teachers teach with the door shut and leave when the bell rings. Ripe: time is built into the schedule for teachers to work together, and they pop into each other’s classrooms informally.
- Leadership values PD. If your administrator does not value adult learning, you won’t have the opportunity to shine. Toxic: there is no budget or time allocated for professional learning. Ripe: the principal plays an active role in planning professional development.
- A common mission and vision. When short-term goals connect to the vision for the school, there is buy-in for change. Toxic: faculty are unclear on the school’s goals and gossip about initiatives. Ripe: faculty can answer “What are we working toward, and what impact will our work have on students?”
- Data is valued. Data helps your school set goals and measure growth with evidence. Toxic: teachers don’t have access to data and administration doesn’t ask for it. Ripe: data is available, teachers know how to interpret it, and it drives policy decisions.
- A sense of trust. Toxic: there is frequent gossip about other teachers, and teachers won’t raise concerns with admin. Ripe: teachers believe their colleagues are trying their best, are receptive to feedback, and respect differences of opinion.
- Focused schoolwide goals. Schools spread too thin accomplish nothing. Toxic: new initiatives get piled on without follow-up, and PD is mostly one and done. Ripe: goals are relevant, based on data, and there are no more than three schoolwide initiatives.
Why a culture of learning comes before professional development
You have to be vulnerable to learn, and that’s where you have to start: creating a safe space for teachers to be vulnerable. If you haven’t built a trusting relationship with a teacher, and you try to have a conversation about something you want him to try, you will likely get a list of excuses about how others are standing in his way.
I have heard teachers say that their students are lazy, their students are too low, their parents don’t care, the district sets up too many obstacles, and on and on and on. When these kinds of excuses pop up, it signals me that the teacher doesn’t believe he is good enough for whatever I am pushing him to do. He sees the low socioeconomic status of the students as a stumbling block, and a shield to hide behind. He doesn’t see it as a challenge to him as a teacher or as an opportunity to serve those who need help the most. Teachers can overcome such attitudes, but they need to know and trust that the people on their team have their back.
How do you build a culture of learning when the school isn’t ready?
Shifting such mindsets must start at the top. The principal should build a growth community by observing often, providing constant feedback, and hosting discussions about strengths and weaknesses. I have learned that I can attempt to do these things alone, but if the principal undermines these ideals by treating observations as a task on her to-do list, never as a valuable opportunity for discussion, or avoids difficult conversations with teachers, then you end up feeling like you are spinning your wheels. It’s important that you and your principal share the same vision for the school, because you will get so much further with fixed-mindset teachers when you are a team. If you do not have the support of the principal, or even if you do but you are blazing the trail, set small, incremental goals that are easy to attain in a short period of time, around the next unit test or a classroom management strategy that takes a small change on the teacher’s part, and praise teachers when the goal is met. It may sound trivial, because you are working with adults, but I promise that a teacher will not turn down her favorite coffee in the morning, with a note from you saying how impressed you are with her openness to grow. Slowly but surely, you will get this teacher to open up to the idea of taking on large changes in her classroom that she initially may have dismissed as being too hard to do. The steps below are the order I work in, and the download gives you the full self-assessment with all the signs for each quality. The full steps, with the tool, are in the download.
- 1Assess the eight qualities of your culture
- 2Create a safe space for vulnerability
- 3Align with your principal on the vision
- 4Set small, incremental goals
- 5Praise teachers when goals are met
- 6Stay persistent and keep it about students
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
Changing a culture is a process
Don’t expect things to change overnight. Stay the course, give praise, keep pushing teachers to see the positive, stay out of the negative talk, and relate everything you do back to improving students’ learning.
Keep reading: Choosing One Coaching Priority When Everything Feels Urgent and Coaching the Teacher Who Doesn’t Want to Be Coached.
Questions people ask
What is a culture of learning in a school?
A culture of learning is a school where adults are safe to be vulnerable about their teaching and expect to grow. It shows up as a growth mindset, teachers who take ownership, time to collaborate, leaders who value PD, a shared vision, valued data, trust, and a small number of focused goals.
How do you know if a school is ready for professional development?
Listen for the language in the building. Teachers in a ready culture ask "What should I try differently?" and pop into each other's rooms, while teachers in a toxic culture blame students, teach with the door shut, and hear about new initiatives with no follow-up.
What should a coach do when teachers resist professional learning?
Start with trust and a safe space to be vulnerable, and get the principal on the same vision so you are working as a team. Then set small, incremental goals a teacher can reach quickly, praise them when they do, and stay persistent, because changing a mindset is a process.
