A coach and a teacher are looking at tomorrow’s science task. It asks students to explain how energy moves through a food web. Then the coach notices the sentence starters. They fill in almost every word. Students will only need to copy three terms from the diagram.
That happens often. Teachers add supports with good intentions, and the thinking slowly shifts from students to the worksheet.
Checking a task before assigning it is one of the quickest ways to raise rigor. It takes a few minutes and makes a big difference in what students learn.
What does it mean to check whether a task makes students think?
Checking a task means looking closely at what students will have to do to complete it. Will they recall, apply, explain, or analyze? Does that match what the grade-level standard asks for?
The Task Rigor Check is a strategy for evaluating the thinking a task requires and then revising or protecting that demand before assigning it. Many educators also use Depth of Knowledge (DOK) levels as a related lens for describing how complex a task’s thinking is.
The check works for unit assessments and daily tasks. When the end-of-unit assessment matches the standard, and daily tasks build toward it, students get steady practice with the thinking they’ll need.
What does a task rigor check look like?
A teacher, or a whole team, places the task next to the standard. They complete the task themselves. Then they ask a few quick questions:
- What thinking does the standard require?
- What thinking does this task require, as written?
- Do any supports remove the thinking students need to do?
- What small revision would bring the task up to the standard?
Sometimes the task is strong, and the job is to protect it by keeping added supports from lowering the demand. Other times a quick edit, like removing a hint or adding a “why” question, brings the thinking back to students.
Go back to the food web task. The coach and teacher keep the question and the diagram. They remove the filled-in sentence starters and replace them with one open starter: “Energy moves from ___ to ___ because…” Students who need more help can use a short word bank. Every student still has to explain the flow in their own words.
The same check works for the end-of-unit assessment. Teams can place each item next to the standard it measures. If an item only asks for recall and the standard asks students to analyze, the team flags it. Then daily tasks can build toward the thinking the standard expects.
How can a coach support task rigor?
Coaches can build task checks into a Coaching Sprint (coaching cycle) with a BIG Goal focused on student thinking. Helpful coach moves include:
- Co-plan with the task. Do the task side by side and compare it to the standard together.
- Rehearse the launch. Practice how the teacher will introduce the task without giving away the thinking.
- Gather evidence during a Snapshot. A Snapshot is a short, focused, non-evaluative classroom visit. Note who is doing the thinking during work time.
- Debrief and decide. Look at student work together and decide whether the task needs more or less support next time.
School leaders can support this work by asking teams to bring one upcoming task to each planning meeting for a quick rigor check.
How do you check task rigor step by step?
Here’s a quick sequence teachers can use before assigning any task.
- 1Read the standard
- 2Complete the task first
- 3Name the thinking required
- 4Check the supports
- 5Revise or protect the demand
- 6Review student work after
- The full steps, the tool, and the Reflect and Apply prompts are in the PDF.Get the download
Watch the training for this strategy in the Simple Strategy Hub.
This strategy lives in Anchor 13, Rigorous Tasks and Application. The Task Rigor Check strategy card supports it. In the Simple Strategy Hub, the strategy card walks teachers through the process, and the coach guide gives look-fors to use during a Snapshot.
Where does this fit in planning?
A task rigor check works best once the teacher knows where the unit is headed. Start with Helping Teachers Know Where a Unit Is Headed, then move on to Helping Teachers Prepare a Lesson Before They Teach It.
Keep reading: Helping Teachers Know Where a Unit Is Headed and Helping Teachers Prepare a Lesson Before They Teach It.
Questions people ask
What is task rigor?
Task rigor is the level of thinking a task asks students to do. A rigorous task asks students to reason, explain, apply, or analyze at the level the grade-level standard requires. Rigor depends on the thinking involved, so a long or hard-looking task isn't always rigorous, and a short one can be.
What is DOK in education?
DOK stands for Depth of Knowledge, a framework for describing how complex the thinking in a task is. Levels range from recall to extended thinking. Teachers and coaches often use DOK alongside a task rigor check to compare what a task asks with what the standard expects students to do.
How do you know if a task is aligned to grade-level standards?
A task is aligned when it asks students to do the same kind of thinking the standard describes. Teachers and coaches can read the standard closely, complete the task, and compare the two. If the task asks for less, like recall when the standard asks for explanation, it needs revising first.
How can scaffolds lower the rigor of a task?
Scaffolds lower rigor when they do the thinking for students. Sentence starters that fill in the answer, step-by-step hints, or word banks that give away the key idea can turn an analysis task into a copying task. Good scaffolds support access while leaving the core thinking with students.
How do you check unit assessments for rigor?
Check unit assessments by placing each item next to the standard it measures. Ask what thinking the item requires and whether it matches the standard. Note any items that only ask for recall when the standard expects more. Then use the assessment as the target for daily tasks throughout the unit.
How can coaches help teachers increase rigor?
Coaches help teachers increase rigor by checking tasks together before they reach students. They co-plan with the standard in hand, rehearse task launches, and notice who does the thinking during a short classroom visit. Then they look at student work with the teacher and decide what to revise next time.
